HomeNewsNumbersUSA Offers a Direct...

NumbersUSA Offers a Direct Approach to the Immigration Debate

NumbersUSA has a simple and very appealing take on the immigration debate.  As the name would suggest, it is to focus on the numbers.  For founder Roy Beck there is a suitable level of immigration.  It is lower than what we take in currently, but it is not zero.  Immigrants can be an asset to the United States, as long as we don’t take in more than our economy can handle.

That’s an idea that Americans should be able to come together around, negotiate, and act on.

Beck, a US Army veteran and journalist with reporting experience in the Midwest and Texas, bases his approach to immigration on two federal government papers.  The first is a bipartisan report headed up by Civil Rights leader Barbara Jordan.  The other is the product of the Clinton White House.  Both recommended that the United States allow around half a million immigrants per year, about half of current legal immigration numbers.

This openness to bipartisanship and focus on the bottom line makes NumbersUSA stand out in the immigration debate.  Unlike some other groups, NumbersUSA is open to immigrants from anywhere in the world. 

NumbersUSA is not particularly concerned with the race, religion, or culture of immigrants.  In their view, immigrants will be assimilated in time as long as their numbers are not overwhelming.  True to its name, NumbersUSA focuses on the bottom line — the number of immigrants allowed into the United States.  Keep that number at a reasonable level, and they should be able to find jobs, homes, and schools.

But being realistic about immigration numbers means understanding what America can and cannot accomplish with immigration.  Beck’s well-known “jelly bean” demonstration is one example.  To illustrate the futility of using immigration as a humanitarian tool, Beck picks out a handful of jelly beans, two or three at a time, to represent the immigrants — legal and illegal — that the United States lets in during a typical year. 

Meanwhile, large bottles of jelly beans stand nearby, representing the number of people in poverty worldwide.  The point: using immigration to alleviate global poverty is futile.  The vast majority of the world’s poor people have no chance of taking advantage of even the most generous immigration plan.

If poverty is your concern, we would be far better off providing technical assistance and financial aid to improve living conditions globally.  That’s the realistic way to go once you understand the numbers.

If anything, NumbersUSA founder Roy Beck is sympathetic toward minorities, especially African Americans.  As he explains in his book “Back of the Hiring Line,” excessive immigration has made it more difficult for Black Americans to find work and escape poverty.  Looking over the history of immigration since the end of the Civil War, Beck finds that Black Americans have made their biggest strides while immigration was low, while they languished whenever immigration was high.

NumbersUSA warns that excessively high immigration ripples throughout the economy.  It depresses wages, especially in low-wage jobs in restaurants, construction, and meat-packing.  It drives up the cost of housing.  It also contributes to urban sprawl and even environmental damage.

Excessive immigration increases poverty in the United States and aggravates racial and social division.  Immigrants themselves can become the victims as opportunities are squeezed, prices are inflated, and living standards are dragged down.

All these factors need to be taken into account when the United States makes immigration policy.  The point is to work out an immigration level that works well for everyone, native-born Americans and immigrants alike.  But Beck and NumbersUSA avoid criticizing legal immigrants: “If the total number of legal immigrants has not been helpful to this country, the individual immigrants bear zero blame.” says Beck.

NumbersUSA doesn’t offer a single easy answer to the problems created by illegal immigration, but they do suggest several actions policymakers can take.  Physical barriers — the wall — have a role to play.  But they also advocate mandatory use of E-Verify by employers to confirm the legal status of employees.

They oppose any federal amnesty or broad attempts to “legalize” illegal immigration as well as state and local initiatives, like “sanctuary cities” that serve to encourage illegal immigration. 

NumbersUSA calls for a stronger enforcement arm to deal with foreigners who violate the terms of non-immigrant visas, especially those who fail to return on time.  They also recommend limiting birthright citizenship to the children of legal residents, doing away with the visa “lottery,” tightening standards for asylum, and other steps to limit immigration to reasonable levels.

For Beck and NumbersUSA it’s not about the immigrants themselves.  Even illegal immigrants deserve humane treatment because they are simply responding to the incentives created by lax enforcement.  It’s not about culture.  American society has tremendous appeal, and practically all immigrants will learn to live in peace with those around them.

To Roy Beck and NumbersUSA it boils down to the number of immigrants we allow in.  Keep those numbers at a level that America’s economy and infrastructure can handle and the rest should work itself out.  It’s not exactly a simple solution, but it’s no more complicated than it needs to be: settle on a reasonable number and make it stick.  That’s a plan that Americans should be able to agree on.

Learn more about NumbersUSA here: https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/numbersusa

- A word from our sponsors -

Most Popular

More from Author

Hospital Discharge Rights and Home Recovery Legal Basics

Leaving a hospital to continue recovery at home is an important...

Plain-Language Pet Folder Habits for Owners Who Travel

Owners who travel with pets, or who leave them with a...

Questions to Ask an Attorney About Pet Agreements

Pet agreements appear in many places, from adoption forms and boarding...

Reviewing Pet Paperwork Each Year Without Losing Renewal Dates

Pet ownership brings a steady stream of paperwork that many people...

- A word from our sponsors -

Read Now

Hospital Discharge Rights and Home Recovery Legal Basics

Leaving a hospital to continue recovery at home is an important milestone for any patient. While most individuals and their families look forward to returning to familiar surroundings, the transition from an inpatient facility to home care involves complex responsibilities. A hospital discharge is not merely a...

Plain-Language Pet Folder Habits for Owners Who Travel

Owners who travel with pets, or who leave them with a sitter or boarding facility, benefit from a folder that holds the essential information in clear, simple language. The folder is not a substitute for professional advice, but it makes everyday details easy to find when a...

Questions to Ask an Attorney About Pet Agreements

Pet agreements appear in many places, from adoption forms and boarding waivers to lease clauses and sitter contracts. Most people sign them quickly, yet the wording can affect money, responsibility and access to a pet. When a document feels unclear, an attorney who works in this area...

Reviewing Pet Paperwork Each Year Without Losing Renewal Dates

Pet ownership brings a steady stream of paperwork that many people never organize. Adoption papers, vaccination certificates, microchip registrations, license renewals and boarding forms can end up scattered across drawers and inboxes. Missing a single renewal date can cause confusion when a pet needs care or when...

Protecting Your Health and Wellness Studio Practice

Establishing a successful health and wellness studio requires attention to both the physical well-being of clients and the structural integrity of the business operations. Whether you operate a physical facility, host community workshops, or manage wellness classes, understanding the landscape of liability and regulatory compliance is a...

Navigating Legal Requirements for Health Application Development

Developing digital products within the health sector requires a careful approach to legal and regulatory frameworks. Founders and development teams face complex challenges, especially when creating platforms designed to track wellness, offer medical insights, or provide health advice. The intersection of technology and healthcare means that businesses...

A Checklist Before Moving a Cat Into a Rented Apartment

Bringing a cat into a rented apartment can be a joyful step, yet it also raises questions about the lease wording, the building rules and the small daily details that affect neighbors and the owner. A tenant who is thinking about adopting or relocating a cat needs...

Common Beliefs About Verbal Agreements for Pet Care Between Friends

Asking a friend to feed a cat, walk a dog or keep an eye on a rabbit while you travel is one of the most natural favors people ask each other. Many of these arrangements are sealed with a quick conversation and a thank-you. Most go smoothly....

Navigating Liability and Compliance for Community Wellness Programs

Creating and managing a community-focused wellness program involves more than just passion and a desire to help others improve their health. It requires a thoughtful approach to structure, safety, and documentation to manage risks that naturally arise when working with groups in a health or fitness context....

Plain Notes on Pet Paperwork Before You Bring One Home

Bringing a pet into a home is an exciting moment, but it also comes with paperwork that many new owners do not expect. Records, registrations and local requirements can feel confusing when they arrive all at once. Getting organized early saves time and reduces stress later. The...

Beginner Questions About Pet Insurance Exclusions

Pet insurance can feel like a maze of definitions, limits and exclusions. Beginners often assume that any vet bill will be covered, only to learn that some conditions fall outside the plan. Understanding the exclusions before enrolling helps you choose a policy that fits your animal and...

A Pet’s Life Stages and the Moments to Revisit Care Plans

A young puppy chews through a corner of the sofa on a warm evening, and the owner begins to suspect that the training plan made on the first day no longer fits the animal. Pets change over their lives, and so do the routines, costs and responsibilities...